Ecobee Good Thermostat Premium & Enhanced assessment: greater … – The Verge

Ecobee has introduced two new good thermostats — the primary for the reason that Ecobee SmartThermostat with Voice Management arrived in 2019 and the primary new merchandise to launch for the reason that firm was purchased by generator giant Generac last fall. The $249.99 Ecobee Smart Thermostat Premium and the $189.99 Ecobee Smart Thermostat Enhanced be a part of the Ecobee3 Lite (now priced at $149.99) in Ecobee’s lineup. Each new fashions can be found now at, Amazon, Lowe’s, Dwelling Depot, and Finest Purchase.

The Premium mannequin addresses a widespread criticism of Ecobee that its thermostats should not as enticing as its essential competitor, the Nest Studying Thermostat. Beforehand all plastic, Ecobee’s new flagship mannequin now boasts a smooth zinc physique and an expanded glass touchscreen. It’s a refined total redesign that provides smoother edges and a slimmer look however doesn’t dramatically break with the corporate’s total fashion. It does feel and appear loads nicer, although.

The Premium thermostat provides a zinc accent, the Enhanced makes use of the identical plastic casing because the earlier fashions.

The brand new interface on the Premium.

The brand new interface on the Enhanced

The thermostat builds on its utility by including an indoor air high quality monitoring characteristic and a brand new radar sensor for movement and temperature detection. It retains the built-in good speaker capabilities (select from Amazon’s Alexa or Apple’s Siri) and nonetheless doubles as a hub for Ecobee’s smart security system, which requires extra {hardware} and a month-to-month subscription.

The Premium additionally comes bundled with one Ecobee Good Sensor (obtainable in separate two-packs for $99.99) for monitoring temperature and movement in one other room of your own home. These wi-fi sensors are one in all Ecobee’s largest promoting factors, regardless of rivals resembling Nest, Honeywell Home, and Wyze imitating them. You place the sensors in numerous rooms so your system can keep a constant temperature in all places in addition to goal your most popular temp to the room you’re in, moderately than simply heating and cooling wherever the thermostat is. How efficient that is will differ based mostly on your property’s structure, building, and the age of your HVAC system.

The opposite new mannequin, the Enhanced thermostat, is $60 lower than the Premium and doesn’t embrace a Good Sensor (though it should work with them) neither is it an air high quality monitor. It has the identical new design and upgraded display however no zinc casing; it’s all plastic. There isn’t any speaker or microphone onboard to allow a sensible assistant, however you possibly can nonetheless use a third-party speaker to manage it together with your voice.

The Enhanced is a wonderful choice if you happen to aren’t concerned with having a voice assistant in your wall and also you’re tremendous with the plastic design. Nevertheless, add good sensors (solely offered in two-packs), and also you’re spending greater than the Premium mannequin. This makes the Enhanced finest as a secondary thermostat in case you have a multi-zone system, stay in a small house and don’t want a second sensor (the thermostat itself has temperature and movement sensors built-in), or don’t desire a speaker and microphone in your thermostat. The entry-level Ecobee3 Lite additionally ditches the good speaker, nevertheless it doesn’t have a built-in movement sensor, so that you’d want to purchase a two-pack to make use of a lot of Ecobee’s good options, making it costlier than the Enhanced.

Essentially the most notable new characteristic (and my private favourite) of the brand new thermostats is the bigger display. It’s a vital enchancment on the previous design in that it each seems to be higher and is less complicated to make use of, particularly for these of us with fats fingers. The thermostat is identical dimension because the earlier fashions, however the colour LCD touchscreen is now 50 p.c bigger, a 4-inch diagonal sq. in comparison with a 3.5-inch diagonal rectangle. The show has been bumped as much as 540×540 pixels, making it sharper in addition to greater. The general result’s a extra seamless and built-in interface than the earlier rectangular house the display occupied, which appeared like a smartphone app caught in your wall.

The bigger display offers the person interface room to breathe, with the controls extra unfold out and simpler to pick accurately. It additionally ditches the infuriating fiddly slider management you used to must take care of to manually change the temperature, changing it with a way more intuitive scrollable temperature wheel with the added choice of plus and minus buttons. Nevertheless, there are nonetheless no bodily knobs or buttons.

The brand new temperature scroll wheel is way simpler to make use of than the earlier interface.

The previous interface remains to be on present fashions however might be up to date later this 12 months.
Picture by Dan Seifert / The Verge

Ecobee gained the additional house for its greater, higher display by changing the PIR movement sensor with a brand new radar sensor. The corporate says this offers extra correct temperature readings and higher occupancy and movement detection, because it spans a bigger vary, has wider angles, and may sense from additional away and round corners. In testing, this proved correct, with the thermostat recognizing I used to be residence even from 15 ft away behind a wall.

The brand new indoor air high quality characteristic on the Premium mannequin had restricted use in my testing. It stayed constantly on “clear” on the dimensions, so I by no means obtained any alerts that the indoor air high quality was poor. If I had obtained one, the app ought to have offered recommendations on the right way to enhance it.

Its placement in my entrance entryway is lower than excellent for this use case. The kitchen is the place the pollution emanate from in my home (in response to testing with other indoor air quality monitors), which is much away from the thermostat and certain producing particulate matter to pollute the air, one thing this doesn’t measure. As a substitute, it solely measures VOCs, carbon dioxide ranges, and relative humidity to calculate a clear air rating, which you’ll be able to see on the machine and within the app. The distant sensors don’t measure air high quality, so you possibly can’t depend on them to assist.

Each new fashions work with Ecobee’s second-gen Good Sensors, and are appropriate with the first-gen variations, too.

The brand new good thermostats have the identical linked options because the earlier fashions. These embrace good scheduling, smartphone app management to regulate the temperature remotely, and computerized temperature changes — utilizing a built-in sensor, geofencing, and a connection to your native climate. The Premium and Enhanced are Power Star licensed, so it’s possible you’ll get a rebate out of your power supplier. In addition they work with Time of Use financial savings and demand response applications in case your supplier gives these. They each work with Amazon Alexa, Apple HomeKit, Google Assistant, SmartThings, and IFTTT.

They each use Ecobee’s present Eco Plus software program, which is on by default. The 2 key options of this are:

  • Good Dwelling & Away Sensing — the place the thermostat makes use of its sensors and geolocation of you and your family members’ smartphone (which is opt-in)
  • Good Scheduling — preset Sleep, Dwelling, and Away schedules that adapt when the system senses you aren’t there, and a Schedule Assistant that screens your habits and suggests schedule modifications (however doesn’t routinely implement them)

These work in live performance with one another, however you can even choose and select which options you need, or disable all of them. For instance, I’ve two zones in my home: upstairs and downstairs. Nobody is upstairs in the course of the day, however I make money working from home, so I wanted to disable Good Dwelling & Away upstairs, because it stored switching to Dwelling regardless that I wasn’t utilizing that house.

Whereas you are able to do every part instantly on the thermostat, you can even handle the system on Ecobee’s net portal or its app. The app is newly redesigned and mimics the brand new interface on the thermostat. This additionally provides extra glanceable details about how Ecobee manages your system. Whenever you make any adjustment — on the machine or utilizing a voice assistant — a notification seems beneath the temperature indicating what state it’s in and when it should subsequent change. You too can faucet on this for extra choices.

The Maintain Period setting is within the app now, too. This allows you to inform the thermostat how lengthy to stay with no matter change you made: 2 hours, 4 hours, Till the subsequent scheduled occasion, Till I alter It, or Ask each time. Beforehand, this was buried within the net settings, making it straightforward to unintentionally go away your thermostat on an incorrect setting.

Regardless of the interface enhancements, the app nonetheless suffers from occasional connectivity points, repeatedly alerting me that it had “misplaced its reference to the server” once I opened it. It at all times reconnected rapidly, nevertheless it slowed down the method of utilizing the app for a temperature change.

The Enhanced thermostat’s essential display displaying the subsequent motion.

The indoor air high quality monitor display on the Premium thermostat.

There have been massive enhancements to Dwelling & Away Sensing since I first began testing Ecobee thermostats, nevertheless it’s nonetheless not probably the most environment friendly method to ensure your system dials it down once you’re not residence. It could possibly take upwards of two hours to alter over; in my testing, often, it didn’t swap in any respect regardless of my being out of the home for 3 hours in the course of a sizzling day with geofencing (known as Autopilot within the app) switched on.

I view this characteristic extra as a security internet. There are extra dependable methods to ensure your system is saving as a lot power as potential if that’s your essential aim with a sensible thermostat. You possibly can manually swap to Away on the thermostat, add a 4-degree setback to a voice triggered Routine (“Alexa, I’m leaving”), or create a HomeKit or SmartThings good residence automation that does the identical once you lock your door or shut your storage door (then do the alternative once you come residence).

The Apple Siri integration has been obtainable on the Smart Thermostat with Voice Control since October of last year, however there’s an improve right here. The Siri animation bubble now seems on the display — a extra seen indication that it heard you than the earlier blue mild strip. It additionally exhibits you what music is taking part in on the backside of the house display. When you decide to make use of Alexa because the built-in assistant, additionally, you will see timers, alarms, and notifications. You might want to have a HomePod Mini in your house to make use of Siri, however the Alexa integration doesn’t require a separate good speaker.

Each thermostats are put in the identical method as earlier Ecobee thermostats. Nevertheless, the wiring plate is formed in a different way, so you possibly can’t do a straight swap.

The again of the Enhanced mannequin with its wiring plate and optionally available mount in case you have holes to cover.

The Premium mannequin has a speaker and microphone inbuilt.

Each Ecobee thermostats additionally work as hubs for Ecobee’s smart security system, Smart Security Complete. A self or professionally monitored safety system beginning at $5 a month, it really works with Ecobee’s glorious $100 SmartCamera (which works with HomeKit Safe Video and has Alexa built-in). It ties in with the thermostat as you need to use the safety system’s door and window sensors ($79.99 for a two-pack) to routinely flip off the HVAC system if a window or door is left open for 5 minutes. It then resumes as soon as the door or window has been closed once more for at the least 30 seconds.

This labored as marketed, sending a notification when any motion was taken and is a neat characteristic. It’s one thing you possibly can arrange your self utilizing contact sensors and a house automation system resembling SmartThings or Apple HomeKit, however Ecobee’s integration requires no setup. It’s computerized. This characteristic solely works with a $5 month-to-month subscription, which additionally provides smoke alarm detection and freeze detection to your thermostat (smoke alarm detection is just on the Premium mannequin because it has a microphone). For $10 a month, you possibly can add skilled monitoring.

The Ecobee Good Thermostat Premium is my new favourite good thermostat.

With all these upgrades, particularly the a lot less complicated person interface and readability on how Ecobee is dealing with your local weather, Ecobee Good Thermostat Premium is my new favourite high-end good thermostat. For years, I’ve most popular the third-gen Nest Studying Thermostat (not the newer Nest), and whereas it’s nonetheless an excellent thermostat, Ecobee is innovating sooner and more durable. The final {hardware} improve to the Nest Studying Thermostat was seven years in the past, and whereas I’m not a proponent of swapping out your good thermostat each two years alongside together with your smartphone, I do wish to see some extra innovation from Nest in terms of good residence local weather management.

Additionally, if you happen to want the utility of distant sensors in your house, Ecobee’s are higher than Nest’s, which solely measure temperature and you must program individually. One benefit Nest nonetheless has is that it doesn’t require a C-Wire; Ecobee provides an influence extender equipment to get round this in case your system doesn’t have a C-Wire, nevertheless it’s not a easy DIY answer. (I didn’t cowl set up on this assessment, however I’ll refer you to our previous Ecobee review if you happen to want ideas, as it’s the identical for the brand new fashions).

Nest nonetheless is without doubt one of the solely good thermostats that doesn’t require any scheduling in your half; you possibly can simply let it study your routine and routinely create a schedule for you. Ecobee comes pre-populated with a schedule, which you must change to suit your habits. That is straightforward to do within the app, nevertheless it’s not as frictionless as Nest’s expertise.

Ecobee works with HomeKit and its Good Sensors and safety system all present up within the Dwelling app.

In case you are seeking to improve from an present fifth-gen Ecobee SmartThermostat with Voice Management, the one motive I can see could be in case your thermostat is in a less-than-ideal location in your house – because the newer fashions have improved and expanded movement detection. Even then, that’s going to be a minor enchancment.

When you’ve got a 4th gen Ecobee and just like the good speaker side, the Premium mannequin has a much-improved speaker and microphone, and one can find this a worthwhile improve. Moreover, your whole present sensors will work with these new fashions.

As I’ve stated, the primary motive to purchase an Ecobee is the distant sensor integration, and there’s plenty of competitors right here, with Nest, Wyze, and Honeywell Dwelling all providing distant sensors. We haven’t examined Wyze’s new sensors, however Honeywell Dwelling’s T9 model now works with HomeKit, which is an enormous motive many individuals select Ecobee thermostats. The T9 is cheaper than Ecobee’s Premium mannequin, and its sensors detect humidity (solely the Ecobee’s thermostat can measure humidity). So, if that’s vital, you would possibly want the T9. Nevertheless, it has a extra old-school thermostat design vibe and no built-in voice assistant, plus no movement sensor within the thermostat itself. As my colleague Dan Seifert stated in his review, “dwelling with the T9 isn’t fairly as good of an expertise as it’s with Nest or Ecobee.”

I’ve already mentioned the Nest comparability, and the Ecobee and Nest thermostat world is as divided because the Android and iPhone worlds — folks appear to like one and hate the opposite. However Ecobee does have a lot better integration throughout good residence platforms. Plus, Ecobee spokesperson Fatima Reyes tells me that its thermostats might assist Matter with a future firmware replace and that additionally they have the aptitude to assist Thread. Nest has solely dedicated to upgrading its new Nest Thermostat, which is a extra primary machine. Matter is the brand new good residence customary coming this fall, promising to enhance interoperability throughout the good residence. Reyes stated they totally assist the usual however don’t have “something concrete to share right now.”

Images by Jennifer Pattison Tuohy / The Verge

Comments are closed.